O8A.ORG

Owners 8 Association
Survey Results
DISCLAIMER:  The opinions and comments of individual franchisees expressed herein are solely the opinions of those individual franchisees and do not necessarily state or reflect the opinions of the Owners 8 Association or its attorneys.  The  information in this website is the sole property of the Owners 8 Association and any duplication or reprint cannot be made without the consent of  Owners 8 Association.  

December 20, 2009
Survey Results from our latest survey below:
 
What PMS system do you currently have?
Answer Options Response Percent Response Count
HSS 40.8% 89
MSI 9.6% 21
Softhotel 33.9% 74
Opera 1.4% 3
Other 14.2% 31
answered question 218
skipped question 2
 
Are you planning to upgrade your software?
Answer Options Response Percent Response Count
YES 3.7% 8
YES- Only as the Franchise is Insisting 34.7% 75
No 50.5% 109
Not Sure 11.1% 24
answered question 216
skipped question 4
 
what amount of money do you consider a reasonable amount for an upgrade?
Answer Options Response Percent Response Count
Less than 1000 31.0% 65
Between 1000 and 2500 35.7% 75
Between 2500 and 5000 27.1% 57
Between 5000 and 10000 4.3% 9
Between 10000 and 15000 1.9% 4
Greater than 15000 0.0% 0
answered question 210
skipped question 10
 
Are you currently satisfied with the PMS system that you have?
Answer Options Response Percent Response Count
YES 66.8% 145
NO 33.2% 72
answered question 217
skipped question 3
 
Do you think wyndham rewards is a valuable marketing tool for your property?
Answer Options Response Percent Response Count
Very Valuable 5.5% 12
Valuable 22.3% 49
Not Very Valuable 39.5% 87
Not at all Valuable 32.7% 72
answered question 220
skipped question 0
 
How likely are you to leave the franchise if there were no liquidation damages?
Answer Options Response Percent Response Count
Very Likely 45.0% 99
Some What Likely 25.5% 56
Unlikely 19.5% 43
Very Unlikely 10.0% 22
answered question 220
skipped question 0
 
How likely are you to renew your franchise agreement with Wyndham Worldwide, if and when it expires?
Answer Options Response Percent Response Count
Very Likely 6.0% 13
Somewhat Likely 26.0% 56
Unlikely 25.6% 55
Very Unlikely 42.3% 91
answered question 215
skipped question 5
 
Do you agree with the Customer service fines and QA inspection fines by franchise?
Answer Options Response Percent Response Count
Strongly Agree 3.2% 7
Agree 12.0% 26
Disagree 27.3% 59
Strongly Disagree 57.4% 124
answered question 216
skipped question 4
 
How satisfied are you with your Franchise Advisory Board?
Answer Options Response Percent Response Count
Very Satisfied 2.8% 6
Satisfied 14.7% 32
Unsatisfied 40.6% 88
Very Unsatisfied 41.9% 91
answered question 217
skipped question 3
 
Do you agree that franchise should receive money from approved vendors in the form of commission?
Answer Options Response Percent Response Count
Strongly Agree 7.8% 17
Agree 7.4% 16
Disagree 16.1% 35
Strongly Disagree 68.7% 149
answered question 217
skipped question 3





O8A Member Survey conducted between August 1, 2008 - September 10, 2008
267 membes responding to survey within 6 weeks.  Results listed below:
     
Do you feel that the presence    
of O8A has positively affected YES NO
 your business? 88.60% 11.40%
     
     
Do you feel that the Brand    
Appointed FAB effectively YES NO
represent your concerns? 16.70% 83.30%
     
         
Rate the following issues that affect the franchisees
Not Significant Significant Very Significant No Opinion
SoftHotels 15.90% 11.60% 63.8% 8.70%
Wyndham Rewards 11.30% 18.30% 69.0% 1.40%
Inspection Fees 19.70% 18.30% 59.2% 2.80%
Guest Complaint Fees 17.10% 17.10% 64.3% 1.40%
         
     
What concerns you the most Cost of the  Functionality 
regarding SoftHotels  System of System
Implementation 68.10% 31.90%
     
           
The Wyndham Rewards Program Agree   No   Disagree
helps increase my  Strongly Agree Opinion Disagree Strongly
Hotel's Revenue 0.00% 11.00% 9.60% 37.00% 42.50%
           
           
Customer Service Agree   No   Disagree
Fees are needed to improve Strongly Agree Opinion Disagree Strongly
Guest Satisfaction 1.40% 4.20% 9.70% 38.90% 45.80%
           
     
Do you feel that Re-inspection    
fees should be accessed to YES NO
properties that fail the first time? 11.60% 88.40%
     
           
The assessment of Guest  Agree   No   Disagree
Complaint fees have resulted in  Strongly Agree Opinion Disagree Strongly
fewer guest service complaints 0.00% 1.40% 19.40% 38.90% 40.30%
           
     
Do you feel that you are being    
charged fairly for SoftHotels or YES NO
any PMS system? 2.90% 97.10%
     
     
Would you leave your Wyndham    
franchised brand if there were YES NO
no penalties? 80.30% 19.70%
     





TRIPREWARDS SURVEY RESULTS FROM O8A SURVEY
Number of Properties Responding to the TR Survey 67
Total # of Guests Polled for the Survey during the Poling week 1766
Total # of Polled Guests  Aware of the TR Program 314
Percentage of Polled Guests Aware of the TR Program 18%
Only 18% of the guests surveyed had heard of the Triprewards program despite the 
fact that Wyndham continues to point towards the program as a reason for growth
Percentage of polled guests with Reservations from CRS 15.40%
Actual Number of CRS Reservations 272
Percentage  of Guests with Reservations Aware of the TR Program 46.60%
Number of Guests with Reservations Aware of the TR Program 91
Percentage of enrolled guests in TR Program   71.69%
# of enrolled guests in TR Program   195
Percentage of TR reservations Charged on motel TR bill 92.70%
# of reservations charged 5% 195
Super 8 Motels reservations contribution accounted for 15.4% of the total revenue
71.69% of the reservations had TR numbers associated with the guests however, 
only 46.6% of these guests were aware of the TR program.  
Note: These statistics represent average values as compiled from data from the participating locations.
Actual results vary by location.
 
 
The data provided by the survey indicates the fact that awareness of the Triprewards Program is much lower than is touted by Super 8 and Wyndham.  More significantly, the fact that only 46% of the guests with Triprewards frequent stay memberships were aware of their membership in the program.  Wyndham charged the 5% extra royalty on over 92% of these reservations.  They are accurately charging the motels the 5% fees however less than half of these guests were aware of the program and the points they had accumulated. 
 
On a related note:
According to the 2006 UFOC for Super 8 Motels:
 
 

2005

2006

 

Jan-Dec

Jan-Dec

*Source

Room Nights

Revenue

Room Nights

Revenue

Brand Web Site

972552

 $       60,319,385.00

1195492

 $     78,932,534.00
Electronic

948974

 $       57,868,354.00

1162527

 $     68,820,450.00
Other

863170

 $       33,034,401.00

792512

 $     33,756,670.00
Property Direct (Triprewards)

2764311

 $     152,798,186.00

3562932

 $   205,785,932.00
Call Centers

1358346

 $       82,845,945.00

1190549

 $     75,796,670.00
Total

6907353

 $     386,684,271.00

7904012

 $   386,684,271.00
 
 
 
 
 
Contribution
 

29.46%

 

33.27%

 
 
 
 
*Source:  2006 Super 8 Motels, Inc. UFOC  Item 19. Pages 64-65
 
 
 
 
**CONSIDER THESE FIGURES:

2005

2006

Total Revenue for Super 8 Motels throughout the system
 $  1,312,573,900.20
 $1,162,261,109.11
Property Direct Reservations as listed above
 $     152,798,186.00
 $   205,785,932.00
Total Revenue from CRS and Res Centers as above
 $     386,684,271.00
 $   386,684,271.00
ACTUAL RESERVATION REV. THRU SUPER 8 CORP
 $     233,886,085.00
 $   180,898,339.00
TOTAL ACTUAL CONTRIBUTION THRU SUPER 8 CORP

18%

16%

**Based on the UFOC information provided by Super 8 above
 
Reported Contribution in the Super 8 UFOC 29.46% in 2005
ACTUAL Contribution after removal of property direct TR reservations was 18%
 
Reported Contribution in the Super 8 UFOC 33.27% in 2006
ACTUAL Contribution after removal of property direct TR reservations was 16%
 
Property direct reservations that were made by the individual Super 8 Motel locations should not be included in the reservation contribution from Super 8 Motels, Inc.  These reservations made DIRECTLY AT THE MOTEL do not truly represent revenue created by Super 8 Reservations.  Triprewards membership numbers are auto assigned by an irregular reservation system created by Wyndham.  In many cases the guests are not aware of their membership and the Triprewards guests are not always legitimately created frequent guests due to the auto assignment of a member number.  Triprewards has nothing to do with many of our guests stays and due to the complete illegitimacy of the current Triprewards Membership base, Wyndham is knowingly skewing these values in order to present more positive reservation delivery values.  Further, due to the fact that Triprewards is not brand specific this further distorts the true contribution values.
 

SURVEY RESULTS OF OUR 1ST SURVEY OF THE MEMBERS
 
Trip rewards Survey Totals
 
90.3% TR not valuable and very poor value
57% very poor value
33.7% no value
 
4% valuable
4% very good value
8% valuable and very good value
 
 
Owners thoughts regarding Wyndham's Direction regarding Super 8
 
Dissatisfied with Direction 39.50%
Very Dissatisfied with Direction 35.80%
Dissatisfied and Very Dissatisfied with Direction 75.30%
Satisfied with Direction 18.50%
Very satisfied with Direction 1.20%
Satisfied and very satisfied with Direction 19.70%
No opinion 4.90%
 
 
Owner Opinion of the Value of the Super 8 brand
 
0% Very good value
46.2% Valuable 
27.5% No Value
25% Very Poor Value
52.5% No Value and Very poor value
1.25% No Opinion
 
Owners Opinion of the FAB
 
1.2% Very Satisfied
1.2% Satisfied
2.4% Very Satisfied and Satisfied with FAB
38.2% Dissatisfied 
51.9% Very Dissatisfied
90.1% Dissatisfied and Very Dissatisfied with FAB
7.5% No opinion

 
Owners Opinion of their DBD
 
12.5% Very Satisfied
32.5% Satisfied
45% Very Satisfied and Satisfied with DBD
30% Dissatisfied
13.7% Very Dissatisfied
43.7% Very Dissatisfied and Dissatisfied with DBD
11.25% No Opinion
 
Owners opinion of the Super 8 Brand
 
0% Very good value
46.2% Valuable 
27.5% No Value
25% Very Poor Value
52.5% No Value and Very poor value
1.25% No Opinion
 
 
Owners Opinion of the FAB
 
1.2% Very Satisfied
1.2% Satisfied
2.4% Very Satisfied and Satisfied with FAB
38.2% Dissatisfied 
51.9% Very Dissatisfied
90.1% Dissatisfied and Very Dissatisfied with FAB
7.5% No opinion
 
Owners Opinion of their DBD
12.5% Very Satisfied
32.5% Satisfied
45% Very Satisfied and Satisfied with DBD
30% Dissatisfied
13.7% Very Dissatisfied
43.7% Very Dissatisfied and Dissatisfied with DBD
11.25% No Opinion
 
Will Owners be Renewing Super 8
 
5% Very likely
22.2% Likely
27.2% Very Likely and Likely to Renew Super 8
24.7% Unlikely
35.8% Very Unlikely
60.5% Unlikely and Very Unlikely to Renew Super 8
12.3% No opinion
 
 
Owners willing to leave Super 8 at a reduced cost NOW
 
29.6% Very Likely
37% Likely
66.6% Very Likely and Likely to Leave Super 8 at reduced cost
16.04% Unlikely 
9.8% Very Unlikely
25.8% Unlikely and Very Unlikley to Leave Super 8 at reduced cost
 
Owners likely to End Franchise Relationships with Super 8 NOW if no Penalties for leaving
 
56.8% Very Unlikely
18.5% Likely
75.3% Very Unlikely and Likely NOT Renew with Super 8
11.11% Likely
7.4% Unlikley
18.5% Likely and Unlikely to leave Super 8
6.1% No opinion
 
 
Owners opinion of Property Managment Systems Results
 
10% Very Good Value
31.6% Valueable
41.6% PMS System Very Good Value and Valuable
22.78% No Value
31.6% Very Poor Value
54.38%PMS System No Value and Very Poor Value
3.7% No opinion
 

Other Survey Results
59% Have Never Owned another Brand
41% Own or Owned other Brands
6% owned Super 8 for 20+ years
21% owned super 8 for 11-20 years
33.33% owned Super 8 for 5-10 years
39.5% owned Super for less than 5 years
51.2% Do NOT live on site
48.8% LIVE on site
97.6% Manage their property
2.4% Use a Management company
18.98% of Super 8's less than 40 rooms
51.9% of Super 8's 41-60 rooms
70.88% of Super 8's are less than 60 rooms
 
15.85% Of Super 8's 61-80 rooms
11.39% of Super 8's have more than 80 rooms
27.24 of Super 8's greater than 60 rooms
Web Hosting Companies